Healthfirst Bronze vs MetroPlusHealth Bronze B-2 - Review & Which one is best?

Alyssa Corso
Alyssa Corso14 Aug 2021

Open enrollment is an important time to compare and contrast health insurance plans so you can have health coverage for the following year. Each plan has its own values and offering so picking the best option for you is essential. There are different tiers of health insurance. In this comparison of Healthfirst and MetroPlusHealth, we are analyzing the bronze plan.

What Does a Bronze Plan Offer?

As part of the metal tiers, bronze health plans have lower costs compared to the other medal categories, and the insurance company typically covers about 60 percent of the costs.

This plan category describes individual health insurance plans with the least expensive premiums and the highest copays and coinsurance amounts.


Is a bronze plan the right fit for me?

A bronze plan may be a good fit for you if prefer:

  • Lowest option for monthly premium (which you will pay every month, whether or not you use the insurance)
  • Highest costs when you are in need of care
  • Bronze plan deductibles  high deductibles, the amount you will pay before insurance pays
  • A low-cost way to protect yourself from worst-case medical scenarios, such as serious sickness or injury. Your monthly premium will still be low, however, most other payments will still be billed to you.


Here's A Comprehensive Breakdown Comparing Healthfirst's Bronze Plan and MetroPlusHealth's Bronze B-2 HSA Plan:

 Healthfirst GoldMVP Health Care Gold
Available on ExchangeYesYes
Monthly premium$752.21$846.69
Out-of-pocket Max$4,000$4,000
Network typeHMOHMO
No referral needed for specialist
Direct messaging
Phone support
Preventative care$0 pre-deductible$0 pre-deductible
Primary care$25 co-pay post deductible$25 co-pay post deductible
Specialty visits$40 co-pay post deductible$40 co-pay post deductible
Urgent care$60 co-pay post deductible$60 co-pay post deductible
Prescription drug deductible$10 co-pay/30-day prescription (retail) and $25 co-pay/90-day prescription (mail order) for Tier-one generic drugs$10 co-pay/30-day retail (deductible waived) and $25 co-pay/90-day mail order (deductible waived) for Tier-one generic drugs
Lab tests$40.00 Copay after deductiblePCP: $25 copay*/Spec: $40 copay*
 Healthfirst GoldMVP Health Care Gold
Hospital Cost$1000.00 Copay per Stay after deductible$1,000 copay/continuous confinement deductible applies
Hospitals in networkNew York-Presbyterian/Lower Manhattan Hospital, Mount Sinai Beth Israel, Mount Sinai Beth Israel, Interfaith Medical Center, Wyckoff Heights Medical Center, University Hospital of Brooklyn, Mount Sinai Hospital, Staten Island University Hosp-North, and moreMontefiore Mount Vernon hospital, SJRH - Park Care Pavilion, New York-Presbyterian Lawrence Hospital, SJRH - St. Johns Division, SJRH - Dobbs ferry Pavillion, Blythedale Children's Hospital, White Plains Hospital Center
Gym member reimbursement✅Up to $400 during coverage year; up to an additional $200 during coverage year for Spouse✅ Up to $600 in rewards and reimbursements with WellBeing Rewards per contract per calendar year
❌ No in network cost share❌ No in network cost share 
Health Image

Get Mira - Health Benefits You Can Afford.

Get doctor visits, lab tests, prescription, and more. Affordable copays. Available in 45+ states. Only $45/month on average.

Monthly Premium 

A monthly premium is an amount you‚d be paying out of pocket monthly for the insurance plan. MetroPlusHealth‚s bronze plan has a slightly higher monthly premium at $477.42 per month while Healthfirst has a monthly premium of $466.16.


The co-pay is a fixed amount you pay for a service or prescription, typically paid before the service. For prescriptions, both Healthfirst and MetroPlusHealth have similar copay policies. For prescription, both insurance options have a $10.00 copay post deductible.


A deductible is an amount paid out of pocket by the patient before an insurance provider will pay any expenses. Expenses are affected due to when they must be paid, either pre-deductible or post- deductible. For primary care, Healthfirst covers three visits before 50% coinsurance is applied post deductible. MetroPlusHealth applied 50% coinsurance post deductible for each primary care visit. 

Health Image

Virtual care for only $25 per visit

Virtual primary care, urgent care, and behavioral health visits are only $25 with a Mira membership.

Hospital Coverage

Hospital coverage is what the insurance would cover if you have to use a hospital whether or not it's planned. There's a 50% Coinsurance after deductible for both Healthfirst as well as MetroPlusHealth.

Urgent Care Coverage

Urgent care coverage includes the amount the insurance would pay for an urgent care visit. MetroHealthPlus and Healthfirst both have a 50% coinsurance post deductible.

Lab Test Coverage

If you are ordered lab tests from a physician or other healthcare professional, lab test coverage is the amount in which the insurance would cover that. MetroPlusHealth does cover lab test coverage at a 50% Coinsurance after deductible. Healthfirst also has 50% Coinsurance after deductible.


Which plan is best for me?

Healthfirst Leaf Plans offer complete coverage, and includes telemedicine (24/7 communication with a participating provider), as well as preventive and annual check-ups, prescription drugs, and more. The Bronze plan includes access to a large network of thousands of providers. No referrals required for specialists, obstetric and gynecologic services, chiropractic services, outpatient mental health, and substance abuse services, pediatric dental care, pediatric vision care (except an ophthalmologist).

MetroPlusHealth offers coverage with no cost-sharing for most preventive services (annual physicals, well visits, select contraception). Non-Standard plans include adult dental and vision coverage. HSA plans are also available for members seeking to maximize their care with a Health Savings Account.

While Healthfirst and MetroPlusHealth have many similarities in their bronze plans, MetroPlusHealth is the better option, especially if you're looking to save more money on a monthly premium and deductible.



Alyssa Corso

Alyssa is a Senior Marketing Associate & Content Writer at Mira. She is passionate about educating others on how to affordably access healthcare.